Chelation therapy- EDTA, DMPS, DMSA, or Zeolite - Let's compare

We live in a toxic world... well I think that has certainly been established. There are a number of different options, though, when evaluating therapies to remove toxins and heavy metals from the body. This article from The Heart Fixer (which is the welcome page for the clinical and research websites of Comprehensive Heart Care and Cardiologist James Roberts) explains them in great detail. Dr. Roberts is NOT associated with Let's Talk Detox. I simply found him on the web while researching and thought you would enjoy the information. Please visit The Heart Fixer for more information about Dr. Roberts and the services he provides.

Dr. Roberts has been providing his patients with chelation therapy (CT), in all of its forms, for 10 years. He passed the written exam of the American Board of Chelation Therapy in 1986 and has participated in the training of other physicians in this technique. Ten years ago there was only one approach to CT, the three hour infusion of Mg-EDTA. Today we have multiple chelating agents, many of which can be administered in more than one way. It will be Dr. Roberts' job to evaluated your need for CT and then to recommend a treatment program tailored to your individual health needs. Basic concepts, EDTA, DMPS, DMSA, and Zeolite will be discussed.

Chelation Therapy - The Basic Concept:

Heavy metals, such as lead, cadmium, arsenic, and mercury, poison key enzyme systems and play a key, causative role in the degenerative, age related disease states that plaque Western society. Our bodies were not designed to deal with these toxins (neither evolution or our maker anticipated the toxic metal exposure experienced by mankind today). We do a poor job of removing them, such that these toxins accumulate over our lifetime. When we are young and healthy we can handle this toxic stress, sequestering the toxins in intracellular dust bins (unless we are genetically predisposed to heavy metal toxicity, such as in the situation of Autism), but eventually our intracellular dump sites overflow, our enzymes systems begin to fail, and then we get sick. This starts with age-related conditions such as hypertension and hyperlipidemia, or we may feel tired for no good reason. In later years metal toxicity may show itself in disease states that end our lives, including heart disease, cancer, or the neurodegenerative diseases associated with advanced age. CT involves the administration of agents that will bind to the heavy metals stored within our body and then escort them out, via the kidneys or GI tract. The goal of CT is to "de-poison" you. While patients typically become interested in CT only when they suffer from an advanced disease state and no other options are available to them (basically because insurers will not cover the cost of CT), the best time to begin CT is well before your get sick. To us, CT is a no-brainer. We feel that CT is one of the most important thing that we can offer you. Standard medicine offers you drugs and surgery, as do we, but it just doesn't make sense to us to drug you and operate on you without at least attempting to detoxify you.

Chelation Therapy - Which approach is best for you?

Good question - the answer will depend on:
A. The types of metals you have on board.
B. Their tissue levels; stated otherwise your toxic burden.
C. Your concomitant medical conditions.
D. Your preference as to route of administration, how quickly you wish to be detoxified, and cost factors.

Our best measure of tissue or body metal burden is the provocative challenge study. It would be neat if your blood level of a specific toxic metal reflected your body burden of that metal, but this is not the case. The correlation between blood and tissue metal levels is limited. We also know that "normal" blood levels of toxic metals are associated with disease states The average or mean blood lead level in American adults is 3.6 ug/dl, and anything below 10 is considered to be "normal". But if you compare American adults with blood lead levels in the upper tercile (top 1/3rd), with levels above 3.6 ug/dl, against those whose levels are in the lower tercile, with levels below 1.9, and follow their course over 12 years, you find that the high normal lead individuals are 25% more likely to die than are their lower lead colleagues. Their 12 year relative risk for death due to heart attack, stroke, or cardiovascular disease in general, in comparison to the lower lead group, are 1.9, 2.5, and 1.5. That's a lot of disease and death associated with blood lead levels well within the normal range. Our conclusion is that there is no normal range for lead; we want to get lead, and any other toxic metals that are in you, our of you. Kids with a blood lead level of 10 have IQs 7 points lower than kids with levels of 0-1 (for more on lead, please look in the medical topics section).

The most accurate means of assessing your body burden of a given toxic metal would be to biopsy your brain, heart, kidneys, and liver - obviously not practical. Instead we carry out a "biochemical biopsy" or Provocative Challenge - we administer to you a chelating agent, a drug or nutritional agent that binds to, and then removes via the kidneys, the toxic metal in question from your system, and then measure its concentration in a subsequent six-hour urine sample. The amount of metal that we see in the urine sample, your "metal spill", will be a function of your body burden of this metal, the integrity of your excretory routes, the specific chelating agent that we administer, and its dose. EDTA binds avidly to lead within your system, but not to Mercury. If we are interested only in lead, we would carry out an EDTA challenge. We would administer 3,000 mg of IV EDTA, then measure the amount of lead excreted over the next six hours. We would see lead, cadmium, a few other metals, but negligible amounts of mercury. We would not see much mercury, no matter your body burden of this agent, because EDTA does not bind to mercury. If we were interested only in mercury, we would carry our a DMPS challenge. Here you would receive 3 mg/kg of DMPS, which binds tightly to mercury, and less avidly to lead. Your urine sample would likely demonstrate an appreciable amount of mercury, and not much lead. If we administered only 1.5 mg/kg of DMPS, we would see a smaller mercury spill, just as we would see less lead if we gave you 1,000 mg as apposed to the usual 3,000 mg of EDTA. DMSA, an orally administered agent, will bind to lead, cadmium, and mercury, but less avidly than would EDTA or DMPS. Comparing metal levels in a post-EDTA urine specimen to the metal spill following EDTA or DMPS would be inappropriate, really an apples to oranges comparison. What we do is to carry out a "triple challenge", administering to you a panel of chelators, each in low to moderate dose, to give us an estimate of your body burden of all the metals of interest to us. For two days you take an oral agent that contains EDTA and garlic (Essential Daily Defense - EDD). On the day of the triple challenge you take a double dose of EDD, then we administer to you 500 mg of oral DMSA, along with 1,000 mg of IV EDTA and 125 mg of IV DMPS. The level of toxic metals in a subsequently collected 6 hour urine specimen serves as our best measure of your body burden of these agents, and will shape the chelation program that we design for you. We will repeat the triple challenge study periodically, using the results to make adjustments in your program, such as when to switch from one chelator to another or whether to switch from active therapy to maintenance chelation, always using the same protocol, allowing for an apples to apples comparison. This is our best methodology but it's not a perfect methodology. Some people with high body metal burdens spill little metal on their initial challenge study. The problem is that they are so poisoned by metal, or so sick in general, that the enzymes involved in basic detoxification and excretion are shot. If we chelate these people for a period of time, and/or take other measures to improve their health, we will typically see a greater spill of metals with subsequent testing. Thus it is not unusual for your challenge report to look worse after a period of chelation. Your metal burden has not increased; what has increased is the functional integrity of your enzyme systems and excretory routs. The determination of your toxic metal body burden is the most important factor in determining our chelation prescription for you, but we will also take in to consideration your specific health care needs, your preferences, and cost factors. The diagnostic Triple Challenge is also discussed on the Diagnostic Studies Available page. Representative challenge findings are presented at challenge results.

Now lets examine the individual chelating agents in common use.

IV EDTA, short for ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid, binds avidly to lead and cadmium, less tightly to aluminum and arsenic, and only weakly to mercury. EDTA administered orally is poorly absorbed; only 2-4% of a given dose will enter the bloodstream. Oral EDTA works by binding to metals dumped into the GI tract by the liver, blocking their reabsorption from the gut back into the circulation (more on this later). EDTA given orally is thus a relatively inefficient approach to chelation therapy; oral EDTA works - it will decrease your body burden of lead, cadmium, and other metals that EDTA can bind to - but it works only slowly. Oral EDTA is used as an adjunct to IV chelation therapy, or as a preventive. Oral EDTA alone is not an appropriate mono-therapy for a sick patient with a heavy body metal burden. On the other hand, EDTA administered IV is an extremely efficient metal chelator. Standard chelation therapy, as it has been practice over the past 50 years, involves a 3 hour infusion of EDTA bound to magnesium (Mg-EDTA). Included in the IV bag will be 5,000 mg of vitamin C, B vitamins, and folic acid. Mg-EDTA removes toxic metals, provides anti-oxidant protection, addresses homocysteine, and provides vitamin C (see vitamin C literature review in the medical topics section) and magnesium, two key nutritionals lacking in the patient with cardiovascular disease and hypertension. We favor IV Mg-EDTA over IV Ca-EDTA for the metal overloaded patient whose primary problems are vascular insufficiency and/or hypertension. While Mg-EDTA requires a 3 hour infusion, Ca-EDTA can be administered over 5-10 minutes. Ca-EDTA does not provide magnesium, vitamin C, or B vitamins, all it provides is EDTA for metal detoxification, but here it is a little more efficient than is Mg-EDTA. We favor Ca-EDTA over Mg-EDTA when hypertension or atherosclerotic vascular disease are not major problems, or for the patients who cannot give up 3 hours once a week for the Mg-EDTA infusions. We typically carry out 20 to 30 IV Mg or Ca-EDTA treatments, and then repeat the triple challenge to monitor progress. IV EDTA is typically administered once a week, but if we are not in a hurry then every two week dosing is OK. We will always recommend oral EDTA as an adjunctive treatment when we treat you with IV EDTA - here's why - I will use lead as an example but the principles apply to all toxic metals. While we do not do a good job of clearing lead, we do try. The liver will filter lead from the circulation and from the food that we ingest. The filtered lead is secreted by the liver cells into bile, which is excreted by the liver into the GI tract, from there expelled into the stool. Lead itself is not water soluble, so the liver cells bind it to a glutathione, so it is actually the water soluble lead-glutathione complex that is excreted into the bile. The problem with this process is that the bond between glutathione and lead is not very tight. If our GI tract is functioning smoothly, the lead is excreted in the stool, but if our GI tract is sluggish, the typical situation in American adults, the lead-glutathione bond breaks before the lead can be excreted. When this happens, the lead is reabsorbed into the bloodstream, while the glutathione molecule is lost in the stool. The reabsorbed lead can be re-filtered by the liver, re-bound to a new glutathione molecule, dumped into the gut, and then reabsorbed. This process accomplishes nothing except for depletion of the liver's glutathione stores. This is a disaster, as glutathione is not only a detoxifier, it is also the primary antioxidant in our system (this is why metal toxicity is so dangerous - the metals poison us and at the same time our futile attempt to remove them weaken us further). However, if we happen to have EDTA in the gut (and 96% of the EDTA that we take in orally will remain in the gut), any lead dumped into the gut by the liver (glutathione-bound or free because the glutathione-lead bond broke) will be immediately scarfed up by the EDTA, and taken out with the stool. Oral EDTA thus converts our innate, relatively inept and self-injurious lead detoxification system into an efficient and effective lead detoxification system. Oral EDTA will also bind up any lead that you take in with your food and water. Concomitant oral EDTA greatly enhances the efficacy of the EDTA that we administer IV, be in Mg or Ca-EDTA. Our standard recommendation is that you take EDD (Essential Daily Defense - oral EDTA, garlic, and several complementary agents - formulated by Dr. Garry Gordon, a leader in the field of chelation), 2 to 6 capsules each day, increasing to 6 to 12 capsules the day before and the day of your IV EDTA treatment. In this fashion we get more metal out, and we improve your tolerance to the EDTA administered IV (When we administer EDTA IV, it binds to lead and most of the EDTA-lead created is excreted via the kidneys into the urine, but some goes out via the liver, from there to re reabsorbed into the circulation, making you feel poorly the day after you receive IV EDTA. However, if you also receive oral EDTA, the lead will not be reabsorbed into the circulation.).

DMPS and Transdermal DMPS-Glutathione

EDTA, the metal binding agent used in classic chelation therapy, binds avidly to Lead, Cadmium, and several other metals, but it has little activity against Mercury. Stated otherwise, EDTA does a poor job of removing Mercury from your body. I don't care is you have received 100 IV EDTA treatments - EDTA simply will not get the job done if the job is to remove Mercury. DMSA, an oral agent, can bind to all three of the above metals, but only weakly. Our most effective Mercury scavenger is DMPS (2-3-dimercaptopropane-1-sulfonate):

DMPS is a di-thiol chelator. Mercury binds, in a nearly irreversible fashion, to thiol groups (-SH) of intracellular structures, such as proteins, enzymes, and DNA. The Mercury damages the structure, and just doesn't let go of the thiol group. This is why Mercury toxicity is cumulative. Mercury can get in to your body with relative ease, but on its own it leaves only slowly. To remove Mercury that is "stuck" to a thiol group, we need to present to the bound Mercury something that it can bind to tighter than one thiol group, such as two thiol groups. The di-thiol chelators, DMPS and DMSA, can pull Mercury off its thiol binding site, and then escort it out of the body. DMPS is poorly absorbed when given orally. Up until recently our approach was to administer DMPS IV, at a dose of 3 mg/kg, up to 250 mg, once a week, with periodic monitoring of the post-DMPS urine Mercury level. This approach was rather expensive, and cumbersome with the need for frequent IV treatments. IV therapy certainly doesn't lend itself well to the treatment of Autistic kids, the majority of whom are Mercury toxic.

Glutathione plays a role in multiple physiologic processes (to liberate one molecule of Nitric Oxide from the sublingual NTG that is taken for angina, one molecule of Glutathione is used up). Glutathione serves as our primary intracellular antioxidant, antioxidant recycler, and detoxifier, and has been demonstrated to be of therapeutic value in certain neurological and cardiovascular conditions. Glutathione can reduce Mercury from its oxidized form, which binds tightly to intracellular structures, to its reduced form, which is easier to mobilize. Co-administration of Glutathione enhances the ability of DMPS to clear Mercury.

The problem with both DMPS and Glutathione, to date, has been their poor oral absorption. IV administration has been required, with its attendant costs and logistical limitations Ė a problem. To solve this problem, Dr. Rashid Buttar developed TD-DMPS‘, a 4:1 ratio of Glutathione and DMPS complexed within liposomes, tiny spherules of fat soluble phosphatidylcholine, which are easily absorbed through the skin. Dr. Buttarís thinking has moved us from IV to a transdermal delivery system for these most effective agents. Both are now absorbed through the skin, enter the circulation, and act as is they were slowly dripped in via the IV route. TD-DMPS‘ is available through AMT pharmacy (a division of College Pharmacy) in N. Carolina (866)-828-8203, as a compounded prescription. We fax a prescription, along with your demographic information, to AMT, and they ship the Transdermal DMPS-Glutathione to you. It is your responsibility to re-order this material when your supply runs low. We have no financial relationship with AMT pharmacy. Writing up all these prescriptions and sending out the faxes is simply part or our overhead Ė so please make it easy for us to help you.

The side-effects of TD-DMPS‘ are typically the side-effects of Mercury detoxification. Many patients feel nothing, while others experience fatigue, irritability, muscle aching, or possibly a transient aggravation of the symptoms that we feel are due to Mercury overload. Minor symptoms can be ignored, but if you feel poorly, simply decrease the dose (such that less Mercury will be mobilized) to a level that you can tolerate. Later try to slowly increase the dose to the target level. As more Mercury is removed, tolerance to treatment typically improves.

We are in no hurry here. Patience is required. At age 50 we are trying to undo 50 years of progressive cellular Mercury overload. We are not going to get the job done in 2 months. Removing 50 years of Mercury is like peeling off the layers of an onion. To monitor progress, periodic challenge studies will be carried out (measuring urine metal levels following the administration of IV chelators), and we will be monitoring your symptomatic status as well.

It is my belief that many of the degenerative, chronic disease states that plague us today are due to, or aggravated by, intracellular heavy metal overload. These toxins bind, nearly irreversibly, to intracellular structures, inactivating them. Mother Nature never anticipated that her children would be exposed to these toxins, so our ability to clear them is limited. For example, it is estimated that, without medical intervention, it takes 20 years for brain Mercury content to fall by 50% following removal of the source of the Mercury. The medical and scientific literature is full of references linking toxic metals like Mercury, Lead, and Cadmium to the diseases of today.

Before beginning a program of metal detoxification, first begin a program of antioxidant and mineral supplementation (a dedicated 6-a-day preparation, 2 tabs with meals); I may recommend other supplements as well, depending on your overall condition. It is critical that you have a chelator in your blood stream when your Mercury Amalgam fillings are removed; coordination between the Doctor and the Dentist is important. Do not take a metal detoxification program if you are pregnant or nursing. Keep up with your mineral supplements, but do not take minerals within 6 hours of a TD-DMPS‘ application (DMPS binds as tightly to Zinc, Copper, and Chromium as it does to Mercury). 5% of patients will experience a rash at the application site. This will resolve on its own; the best approach here is to rotate the application site. If you develop an infection, hold TD-DMPS‘ until the infection resolves. If you feel poorly, lighten up on the dose for awhile and take extra minerals. If that doesnít work, give us a call during office hours or move up your follow-up appointment. We have found that DMPS and other metal chelators work best within a negative field magnetic environment (see discussion in Magnetico sleep pad and oral DMSA in preparation for MME on the MME site).

DMSA, like DMPS, is a di-thiol chelator. Unlike DMPS and EDTA, DMSA is well absorbed. DMSA is not a very powerful chelator, but taken over a period of time, particularly within a magnetic environment, DMSA can provide you with effective chelation. In the doses that we utilize (500 mg once or twice a day) side-effects are rare. Rash can occur, most likely on the basis of Mercury detoxification through the skin. Kidney and liver toxicity in this dosing range is quite unlikely. DMPS, more powerful than DMSA, does not get into the nervous system, while DMSA does. Many clinicians recommend "de-bulking" the Mercury with DMPS, then finishing up the job with DMSA. However, we have seen an improvement in neurological function following the use of DMPS-Glutathione, especially in Autism. It may be that DMPS does such a good job of removing Mercury from the rest of the body that a "concentration gradient" for Mercury is created, such that Mercury is "drawn out" of nervous tissue following the gradient. Dr. Bonlie, the inventor of the MME device and the world's expert of magnetic chelation, prefers DMSA over DMPS, and we use DMSA as our chelator of choice during MME treatment. I have become comfortable with the use of Transdermal DMPS-Glutathione, and prefer this compound to DMSA, particularly in kids with Autism. IV DMPS is now used only in the context of triple challenge or DMPS/DMSA Mercury challenge studies. Mercury and DMSA are discussed further in the Medical Topics section of this website.

Zeolite, technically a mineral, consists of alternating Silica Tetra Oxide and Aluminum Tetra Oxide crystals that arrange themselves in a lattice-like configuration. The compound has a negative electrostatic charge, while toxic heavy metals have a positive charge. Zeolite thus provides an extensive negatively charged surface area that can attract and bind negatively charged toxic metals. The Zeolite-metal complex is then excreted from the body. The Aluminum is locked in to the Zeolite structure and is not retained within your body. Zeolites have been used extensively in water processing, have been shown to be of value in bacterial diarrhea (it binds to bacterial toxins too), and are now being used in animal and human detoxification. Zeolite is less potent a chelator than are the chemical agents such as EDTA, DMSA, and DMPS, and we do not have a long-term track record with the use of Zeolite in chelation therapy, but this material appears to be quite safe. Zeolite makes chelation therapy affordable to everyone. I think this is important. I feel that every adult American should be on some form of ongoing, low-level chelation therapy. I feel this way because I know that every American adult is loaded with toxic substances. I'd prefer to get this garbage out of you before you become ill, but you don't want to do this, either because you do not understand the importance of detoxification, or because of the cost and time commitment associated with the IV chelation techniques. Well, nobody is too busy to take one teaspoon of Zeolite in water or juice every day, and nearly all of us can handle the low cost per month over one to two years of Zeolite chelation. We often use Zeolite along with DMSA during MME. We recommend that you take Zeolite on an empty stomach, 1-2 hours away from food, minerals, or prescription agents.

IV EDTA and DMPS are pharmacologic agents and can be administered only by a licensed medical practitioner. DMSA can be obtained over the counter or by prescription. Oral EDTA and Zeolite are considered to be supplements and are available only over-the-counter.

DeToxMax - DeToxMax consists of EDTA, magnesium, and lipoic acid admixed with microencapsulated Phosphatidylcholine. DeToxMax provides an effective oral delivery system for EDTA and Phosphatidylcholine, the two most important molecules in nutritional cardiology. For more information and case studies please click on DeToxMax.

Chelation Safety Issues - Chelation therapy is safe.

Remember, we are taking poisons out of you, not putting poisons in (which in a sense we are doing with drug therapy). Still, there are issues of patient safety and treatment tolerance that we should address. The chelating agents that we administer to you do not stay in your body. They bind their target metals, and then the metal-chelator complex exits the body via the kidneys or GI tract. It is possible to overwhelm the body's excretory routes with too much metal. Let's say that you are loaded to the gills with lead, and you already have some pre-existent kidney damage. If we gave you a large dose of IV EDTA, we could mobilize far more lead than the already dysfunctional kidneys be handled. Some of the lead could get "biochemically stuck" within the kidneys and kidney function could be compromised. If we did this over and over, without checking on kidney function, we could damage the kidneys. On the other hand, studies have shown that EDTA chelation actually slows down the rate of kidney deterioration in chronic kidney disease (see Lead discussion in the Medical Topics section of this website), and this has been our experience as well (see Case Study - Kidney function improves with chelation). The key point here is to administer the EDTA in a slow and steady fashion, at a dose that the kidneys can handle. We will determine your dose of EDTA as a function of you body size and your baseline kidney function, and we will monitor your kidney function with periodic lab studies, and then adjust your EDTA dose accordingly. If we add a new drug that might affect kidney function (say a diuretic, ACEI, or spironolactone for heart failure), then we will recheck your kidney function to determine if a change in your EDTA dose is appropriate. If another Doctor changes your drug regimen, please let us know, as this may influence our decision making as well. We may recommend that you take nutritional agents that seem to help kidney function, such as asparagus extract or N-Acetyl Cysteine. While chelation therapy with EDTA does not affect liver function, some of the EDTA-metal is removed via the liver; to support liver function we may recommend Mild Thistle Extract (Silymarin) and N-Acetyl Cysteine.

Detox Reactions and Patient Tolerance - Some people are so toxic that when we mobilize the offending metals they experience a "detox reaction". They feel poorly, with muscle aching, fatigue, and nausea. Mercury overloaded individuals may experience a rash or irritability. While you certainly are not enjoying your detox reaction, it does mean that we are barking up the right tree. These metals do need to come out, but of course we do not want to torture you in the process. What we do here is to slow down the process, decreasing the dose of your chelator, and/or increasing the time interval between treatments. We may administer 1 or 2 IVs containing vitamin C, minerals, and glutathione, without a chelator. Symptoms occurring the day after chelation are typically related to GI re-uptake of metal-chelator complexes cleared by the liver into the gut (see discussion above). Here we increase the oral component of your program to help trap the toxin within the GI tract. Muscle aching and muscle spasms typically reflect mineral deficiency. The chelators bind preferentially with toxic metals, but they can bind to and remove from your body nutritional minerals as well. All patients receiving chelation should be on a 6-a-day vitamin and mineral supplement. We ask you to "divorce" the minerals from your chelation. Take your minerals as far apart from your chelator as is feasible. Do not take oral minerals on the morning of IV EDTA; take them that night instead. If you are applying transdermal DMPS-Glutathione at bedtime, get your minerals in by dinner that night and start up again at noon the next day. If you do take your minerals and your chelator at the same time, nothing will go wrong, but the chelator may bind up the nutritional mineral that you just took. You won't get the benefit of the mineral, and you won't get the benefit of the chelator. If you do experience muscle aching, the first thing to do is to increase your mineral supplementation.

Costs and Politics - Your insurer will not cover chelation therapy. Many will say they do, and they may even put this in print in their brochures, but they will not cove the cost of your chelation. When pushed they will say that your chelation was "medically unnecessary". You can appeal, and a doctor who knows nothing about chelation therapy, a doctor who works for the insurance company, will review the records and tests that we send in and conclude that it was "medically unnecessary". There is nothing that we can do about this and the insurance companies know this. They may insist on an elevated blood lead level to confirm the diagnosis of lead or mercury overload. Anyone with even a passing knowledge of the scientific literature will tell you that blood levels do not correlate well with body metal burden in adults but your insurance company will still insist on a blood lead level. I will not bill your insurer for chelation therapy administered in my office. I do not care what they say in their literature. If you want to undergo chelation therapy and have it billed to your insurer, please have your chelation therapy done elsewhere.

I was taught by my professors that chelation therapy was ineffective and that its practitioners were "quacks". I believed this and as a young doctor I parroted this nonsense. It wasn't that I was stupid. It wasn't because I was arrogant (well maybe a little). It was because going in to medical school/residency training, we soon-to-be physicians know nothing and we believe what we are told by our teachers. It really takes being out in the real world for 10 years to see that not everything that we were taught is correct. My "awakening" to the benefits of chelation therapy in cardiovascular disease is discussed in Reverse Heart Disease Now. Briefly, a number of my personal patients underwent chelation therapy behind my back and got better. They got a lot better. It was embarrassing. So I learned how to do it so more of my patients could get better. Some inoperable patients got better. My colleagues did not appreciate my new skill, or the direction I took back then to bring my practice to where it is now. I lost the friendship and respect of everyone (doctors, nurses, hospital administrators) who I had worked closely with for a decade. Patients left my practice, because they were told that I was a "bad doctor". Social friends learned that I was a "dirty doctor". Old friends began to shy away from me at our kids little league games. Lies and juicy half truths were sent in to the Medical Board. I stuck to my position as I was doing nothing wrong. No actions were taken against me. I am 51 years old and have never been sued and have never been sanctioned (I was an Eagle Boy Scout so what do you expect!). I weathered the storm and am now stronger and smarter than I was back then. So please do not expect me to defer to the wishes of practitioners who have not had a new thought in their head over the past decade. Do not expect me to put politics ahead of science. Do not expect me to compromise my judgment just to get along. On the other hand, if you want to pick a fight with your other doctors or with your insurance company, do not try to drag me in. Do not expect me to chelate you if any of us feel that chelation might compromise another, ongoing treatment. Do not expect me to chelate you "on the sly", without the knowledge of your other doctors. Do not expect me to chelate you for free. I did not render you metal toxic, so I have no obligation to detoxify you for free. I will be up front with you and you must be upfront with me - basically we all have the follow correct principles.

James C. Roberts MD FACC
12/07/06



My Note - I really really like this doctor from reading the last 2 paragraphs which show such a human side. As a "retired" cardiac care nurse, I know only too well how rare this is in a cardiologist. I have included many links to Dr. Roberts website (and one to his book), but in case you missed them, please visit http://www.heartfixer.com/


Category: Detox Solutions
10 Comments
  1. Hello, i am chelating for mercury, arsenic and cadmium and have been using oral alpha lipoic acid with dmps. I follow the low dose hi frequency protocols suggested by Andrew Cutler. Typically i go for 1 week of ALA every 4 hrs and dmps every 8, both of these around the clock for 4 to 10 days. This is followed by a break of 4 to 10 days. Can you advise if it is ok to alternate the dmps for dmsa provided that there is a time space of about 1 week between use?

    Thank you, Marvin

  1. Hello, i am chelating for mercury, arsenic and cadmium and have been using oral alpha lipoic acid with dmps. I follow the low dose hi frequency protocols suggested by Andrew Cutler. Typically i go for 1 week of ALA every 4 hrs and dmps every 8, both of these around the clock for 4 to 10 days. This is followed by a break of 4 to 10 days. Can you advise if it is ok to alternate the dmps for dmsa provided that there is a time space of about 1 week between use?

    Thank you, Marvin

  1. I can't offer medical advice. I simply report the news. Others may be able to offer insight, but I can not.

    Thanks Marvin for your question.

  1. pair of tights

    On many levels, I am more amazed by the so called generic commenter_
    than I am by the out and out spammer. Why? Because at
    least the obvious spammer is more open and honest with their spam!
    I know what they are trying to do. The generic commenter is a con man and also a faker!
    You can probably spot that I have very strong opinions towards
    this group of people

  1. ChrisSoto

    Hello, i have found a source for cheap DMPS, if anyone interested. DMPS without a prescription, sold as a detox system for people who cannot quit smoking:

    http://detoxitab.com/

    But no matter the reason it's DMPS of a great quality for a good price.

  1. Bring <a href="http://www.monclerejacketsu..."><strong>Moncler jackets for women uk</strong></a>them easily during your winter vacations and have fun without compromising in your comfort and warmth.

    Moncler has already established the honor of being chosen for designing apparel with the French Olympics team and their lightweight collection specially suitable for in france they skiing team have been the stepping-stone for
    <a href="http://www.monclerejacketsu..."><strong>Moncler Men's Jackets</strong></a> Moncler's lightweight jackets in the market today. Today Moncler is definitely within the most popular premium luxury brand for outdoor and sport jackets. Adrienne Ma offers Moncler to China<a href="http://www.monclerejacketsu..."><strong>Moncler Kids Jackets</strong></a> recently plus the inaugural shop was opened in Hong Kong. Moncler jackets were a total sale-out within days of the inaugural.

    Make your winters fashionable by introducing Moncler
    <a href="http://www.monclerejacketsu..."><strong>Moncler UK Sale</strong></a>jackets on your winter collection. Endorsed by many celebrities, Moncler is a brand containing maintained its foothold from the fluctuating garment industry for some time now and promises to keep doing so down the road too.

    Go back home<a href="http://www.monclerejacketsu..."><strong>Moncler Uk Outlet</strong></a> a Moncler jacket and jump to the an entire world of fashion called Moncler.

  1. The[url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler UK Sale[/b][/url]duck-down collection of Moncler is at high-demand likewise. The perfect

    cuts[url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler Jackets UK[/b][/url] to offer you a fitted jacket full of genuine duck-down promises to

    make
    [url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler kids coats sale[/b][/url] your winters comfy. The

    jackets can be easily stored with minimum fuss as they are not simply lightweight but in addition take minimum storage place. Storage in a tiny bag on a trip

    is not[url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler Kids Jackets[/b][/url] a challenge with Moncler

    jackets. Take them easily during your winter vacations enjoy yourself without compromising on your own comfort and warmth.

    Moncler has received the honor to

    be chosen[url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler Men's Jackets[/b][/url] for designing apparel

    to [url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler jackets for women uk[/b][/url]the French

    Olympics[url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler Kids[/b][/url] team and their lightweight collection specially

    intended [url=http://www.monclerejacketsu...][b]Moncler for Men[/b][/url]for in france they skiing team may be the stepping

    stone for Moncler's lightweight jackets already in the market today. Today Moncler is amongst the most coveted premium luxury brand for outdoor and sport

    jackets.

    More Articles:
    [url=]http://www.swissarmedforces...[/url]
    [url=]http://www.expert-esports.c...[/url]
    [url=]http://extremeprocups.com/i...[/url]
    [url=]http://www.stosstrupp-gold....[/url]
    [url=]http://www.seyko-gaming.com...[/url]

  1. http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Outlet
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Outlet Online
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Outlet Store
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... michael kors outlet
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... michael kors outlet online
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... michael kors outlet store
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... michael kors factory outlet
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Hoodies
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Sweatshirts
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Jackets
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Sweaters
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Down Jackets
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Down Vests
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Outerwear
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Shorts
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Shoes
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Polos
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren T-Shirts
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Long Sleeve Polos
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Shirts
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Sweaters
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Outerwear
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Dresses
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Shorts
    http://www.poloralphlaureno... Ralph Lauren Swimwear
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... New Arrivals Michael Kors
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Tote Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Satchel Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Skorpios Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Kingsbury Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Jet Set Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Hamilton Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Gansevoort Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Grayson Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Mini Crossbody
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Classic Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Shoulder Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Messenger Bags
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Clutches
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Wallets
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors iPhone Case
    http://www.michaelkorsoutle... Michael Kors Watches

  1. Hello, i think that i saw you visited my website so i came to _return the favor_.

    I am trying to find things to improve my website!I suppose
    its ok to use a few of your ideas!!

  1. http://www.abercrombiesoutl... abercrombie outlet
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch T-Shirts
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Long Sleeve T-Shirts
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch Polos
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Long Sleeve Polos
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch Sweaters
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch Hoodies
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Fitch Fur Hoodies
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch Jackets
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Fitch Down Jackets
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Fitch Down Vests
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch Pants
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie & Fitch Hoodies
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Fitch Fur Hoodies
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch Sweaters
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie and Fitch Jackets
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Fitch Down Jackets
    http://www.abercrombiesoutl... Abercrombie Fitch Down Vests
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin 2012
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Pumps
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Sandals
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Booties
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Boots
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Ankle Boots
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Shoes
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Flats
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Daffodile
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Bridal Shoes
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Platforms
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Galaxy
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Peep Toe
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Slingback
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Evening
    http://www.christianloubout... Christian Louboutin Mens Shoes
    http://www.christianloubout... Jimmy Choo Shoes
    http://www.christianloubout... christian louboutin outlet

[prev post] [next post]